Purple Pitchfork
  • Home
  • Podcast
  • About Chris
  • Farming Resources from Chris
  • Donate

Not 2,000 Miles Fresher

4/23/2015

1 Comment

 
Quality tends to fan out like waves. The Quality job he didn't think anyone was going to see is seen, and the person who sees it feels a little better because of it, and is likely to pass that feeling on to others, and in that way the Quality tends to keep on going. - Robert M. Pirsig, Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance.

When I took over management of Beech Hill Farm in Maine - this was almost twenty years ago now - we harvested product for sale six days each week. On Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays, we would harvest for same-day deliveries to stores and restaurants around Mount Desert Island; on Tuesdays, Thursdays, and Saturdays, we would harvest for sale in the farm's store, which was open those days starting in late morning.

Six days of harvest every week, and everything done in a just-in-time fashion! Having come most recently from a farm that harvested large quantities throughout each week and delivered almost everything to a distant market on Saturday, I was frustrated at the multiple harvests of small quantities of product - I knew that we were losing a huge amount of time to switching between crops.

Then we went to meet with our wholesale customers that fall, and I heard again and again that, "The quality is great, but the lettuce just doesn't last."

I decided to change things up. Instead of harvesting six days each week, we changed our harvest to three days each week - Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays, for delivery and sale in the store on Tuesdays, Thursdays, and Saturdays. We got some push-back from the stores, because this meant they had to place their orders a day earlier - and our lettuce in the past hadn't been lasting for two full days, so they didn’t feel confident of their ability to predict what they needed.

I was surprised at the results. I had expected some modest gains, but we discovered that harvesting ahead, and the thorough cooling that resulted before we delivered our product, meant that product lasted much, much longer than it had before once it reached our customers' shelves. As a result, our customers actually increased their orders because our product was no longer super-perishable - over-ordering wasn't the huge risk that it had been before.

Plus, harvesting ahead saved time as we batched lettuce harvest into three days instead of six, reduced stress as we weren't working under deadline to get deliveries out the same day, and improved our customer service because any shorts became apparent a full twenty-four hours before our scheduled delivery. In addition, we were able to do deliveries in the cool of the morning, when tourist traffic was at a low ebb.

When I started Rock Spring Farm in Northeast Iowa several years later, we took this lesson to heart, and invested in a walk-in cooler our first year in production - and it made a huge difference. Rather than selling produce three days each week, we sold at farmers market one day each week. Our get-it-cold-fast philosophy gave us a huge marketing advantage, since we were able to guarantee a full 10-day shelf-life for our salad mix. We would often give away salad mix to customers who had already purchased theirs from another vendor, with a promise that it would still be good to eat the night before the next farmers market.

The biggest complaint I hear about local produce is that it doesn't have the shelf-life that produce from California does, even once it arrives here in the Midwest. The University of California at Davis suggests that Romaine should have a 21-day shelf-life at proper storage temperatures - that's our competition in the quality department. The whole idea of 2,000 miles fresher doesn't mean a thing if we aren't able to provide the shelf life that our customers need to move product through the distribution chain. And it's just as important for retail customers in a CSA or at a farmers market, since a long shelf life allows customers to buy more produce, and have the time to figure out what to do with it - or even to figure out when in their crazy day-to-day lives they are going to have time to prepare it.

At a practical level, I recommend that nothing goes to market, or gets packed into a bag or a CSA box, unless it has had at least twelve hours in the walk-in cooler to reach its desired storage temperature.

Picture

1 Comment

Lowering Prices

11/27/2014

0 Comments

 
Black Friday has me thinking...

If you decide that you want to lower your selling price, you need to get something substantial for that. Lower prices should only be a reward for the customer who helps you drive down your acquisition costs, increase your utilization, or sell a lot more product.

CSA farmers often provide a discount for early purchases, and I've seen this more and more with the "market CSA" model where customers get a punch card to shop at a farmers market stand. Before you do this, you have to ask: does getting money up front reduce my overall expenses? Can I "borrow" the money from my customers for less than I could borrow it from the bank?

In that same model, you would also want to ask if providing a discount at your stand helps you to make better use of your fields or your product selection? One of the curses and advantages of farming for a CSA is the requirement to grow a lot of different crops - it's hard, but it also means you have the opportunity to get increased value on low-value crops by including them in the same box; for example, we used to include greenhouse greens in a box of winter roots, effectively increasing the value of the turnips by packaging them with the fresh greens.

Finally, does providing a punch card help you sell more product - and does it help you sell enough more product to offset the lost profits from the discounted produce? If you are making a 30% margin on your crops, and you give your customers a 10% discount, you are cutting your profits by a third.

The same questions apply to dropping prices in any situation. Does decreasing your price allow you to sell a lot more product - like moving pallets of broccoli to a wholesale distributor?  Does it drive down your costs - like saving the time and expense of going to farmers market? Does it get you needed cash flow to pay staff until you get to a more profitable crop? (Are you sure?) Does it help you put together a load that includes high-margin crops?

Never lower your prices for the sole purpose of selling products - sales without profit is just work.

0 Comments

The Extras Aren't Extras

1/16/2014

0 Comments

 
The basket of goods and services you provide to your customers has more in it than the explicit stuff. It’s not just the vegetables and the delivery and the newsletter - it’s the box you put the produce in, the label you put on the box, the invoicing system you use, and more.

People who buy your fruits and vegetables aren’t just buying produce and a newsletter, they’re buying everything that goes into buying that produce, from the way you present it to the story you tell about why and how you got into farming. Farmers market customers are buying clean and fresh farmers in addition to clean and fresh vegetables, and wholesale buyers buy a communication and delivery schedule in addition to their produce.

You can one-up the competition by doing exceptionally well at adding real value with service and consistency where your customers don’t even know that they expect it. At the wholesale level:
  • Provide a clean, well-designed, and organized invoice, including your contact information;
  • Use an email service like MailChimp to schedule availability notices at the same times every week (you can do the same with faxes);
  • Promptly document credit requests for products that don’t meet expectations;
  • Verify your customers’ overdue payment status every month, and let them know about anything that’s missing - including applying a credit to an invoice.

At farmers market:
  • Clearly identify prices for your products where customers can easily see them (putting the price for radicchio on a chalkboard behind the stand does not make it easy for customers to identify the vegetable or its price);
  • Be prepared with at least one “week-night” preparation for every product on your stand, and make sure your helpers have the same knowledge;

For a CSA:
  • Provide a straightforward sign-up process (this doesn’t have to be an online shopping cart - Fair Share Farm in Missouri requires members to come to a sign-up event - the process just needs to be linear and clear in its description of options and process.
  • Let members know what to expect in their share before you deliver it - at the same time every week;
  • Make box return easy by providing instructions for unfolding boxes;
  • At delivery sites, keep the boxes off of the ground to keep them clean and sanitary.

You’re always selling more than what you’re selling, and the extras are part of the price that your customer pays for their produce.

0 Comments

CSA vs the Box Plan

8/18/2012

0 Comments

 
In the CSA community and online, much has been made of the growth of box plans that resemble traditional Community Supported Agriculture programs in packaging and marketing, but don’t provide the same retail-level pricing and community support that formed the core of the original CSA concept.

To me, this all comes down to a marketing issue. In favor of a short acronym, we’ve all dropped the Community and Supported aspects of the concept from the every-day language we use to describe this way of marketing vegetables, with the result that CSA has (in the same way that Kleenex now means anything you use to blow your nose) come to imply any delivery of vegetables in a box.

CSA needs a new name. Or maybe it’s an old name that harkens back to some of the original writings on the subject of Community Supported Agriculture, such as Trauger Groh’s Farms of Tomorrow. In any case, it needs to be short and snappy, and it needs to say something about those two core values of community and support.

The new name, and indeed the movement as a whole, will need to find a way to draw the line of who is in and who is out – the lines aren’t as clear as you might think. At one end of the spectrum you’ve got programs that never reference the term CSA and make no representation about actually producing the food, such as Chicagoland’s Irv and Shelly’s Fresh Picks, and farm-based companies like the Pacific Northwest’s Full Circle that have added on to their own production to such a degree that the farm’s own produce doesn’t represent the cornerstone of their distribution program any more.

But you also have farms that supplement their own production from area growers, as well as others that offer add-on programs to supply out-of-region items like fruits and coffee to their members. For some of these farms, the add-on items include an implicit connection to a social-justice movement or even directly to the producer; for others, it’s just a box of good fruit.

The organic movement went through this definition process about 30 years ago, when organic certification began to define who was and who wasn’t organic long before the government got involved. I think it’s time for Community Supported Agriculture to do the same.

0 Comments
    Picture

    Sponsors

    img_purple pitchfork_sponsor_vermont compost

    Archives

    2016
    2015

    2014
    2013
    2012
    2011

    Announcement
    Business Philosophy
    Business Strategy
    CSA
    Entrepreneurism
    Farm Equipment
    Farm Finances
    Farming Techniques
    Farm Labor
    Farm Systems
    Farm Wisdom
    Food Safety
    Government
    Health
    Irrigation
    Management
    Marketing
    Organic Certification
    Organic Farming
    Organization
    Pricing
    Records Management
    Scaling Up
    Value

    Picture

    RSS Feed

Picture
Purple Pitchfork is a project of Renewing the Countryside, a non-profit dedicated to rural revitalization and collaborative farmer education that serves as the home for these resources Chris Blanchard created.
Copyright © 2018, Purple Pitchfork. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy