Purple Pitchfork
  • Podcast
  • About Chris
  • Tools
  • Donate

Picking the Perfect Winter Squash

9/17/2015

3 Comments

 
The vast majority of winter squash out there is insipid and boring. Every now and then, the average consumer will pick a winner by blind luck, and they’ll be thrilled. But for every sweet and delicious squash they find, they get several duds.

The flavor, nutritional value, and keeping qualities of winter squash depend absolutely on the maturity of the fruit at harvest – and that’s not always easy to determine.

At farmer’s market, customers often asked me how to pick a good winter squash, to which I would invariably reply, “At my stand, you can pick any squash and we guarantee it will be sweet. But let me show you how to find a ripe squash in case you want to buy one from somebody else.” We were able to consistently charge up to three times the going rate for winter squash at farmers market by guaranteeing the eating quality of every squash we sold; at wholesale, we were able to push a 20% premium when we applied this to certain specialty varieties – acorn squash, not so much.

Eating quality in squash has two main components: sweetness and texture. Texture is largely controlled by genetics, although high storage temperatures can cause the flesh to become stringy. And while the sugar content has a large genetic component –think sweet corn – it continues to increase as the squash fruits mature. Nutritional content, especially carotenoid levels, also continues to increase while the squash is on the vine.

That’s why you want to leave the squash on the vine until they are fully ripe. Of course, sugar content and nutrition only increase when there is adequate photosynthesis, so disease and insect control to avoid defoliation is a critical component of getting a good squash harvest, even though you may get an acceptable overall yield without full leaf cover.

Good leaf cover also provides protection from a first, light frost. If you can get your squash patch through the first frost and into the Indian summer that often follows, it is possible to gain a couple of weeks of maturation time for your crop. But, in general, plan to get your crop out of the field before the first hard freeze.

Squash pick up a lot of sweetness during the cool nights of autumn. As they grow, most of the sugars plants produce through photosynthesis are combined and stored in the plant as starches and other large polymers. But in response to cold temperatures, so plants – including squash – break down some of this stored energy into “free” sugars such as glucose and fructose, stashing the sweet stuff in their cells to protect against frost damage. Bonus for squash eaters: that free sugar also makes the plants taste sweeter.

As an additional advantage, fully ripe squash store much better than even their slightly under-ripe counterparts.


Harvest Cues

Squash commonly grown in the northern part of the continent come from three species, all in the genus Cucurbita: C. pepo, C. maxima, and C. moschata. Each has its own cues for ripeness.

Because each plant ripens several fruits in succession, starting with the fruit closest to the central stem, entire fields of squash are never ripe at the same time. Harvesting consistently great squash means you have to leave some in the field.

Although many sources say that you should test all squash for ripeness by trying to pierce the skin with a fingernail, this is simply unacceptable in a commercial setting – how many customers want to buy a damaged squash?

Cucurbita pepos include the Acorn and Delicata types, as well as pumpkins. All pepos have a hard, angular stem with five sides (the “stem” on a fruit is technically called a peduncle, which is much more fun to say than “stem,” but not universally understood), and tend to produce smaller fruits than other species. Where they touch the ground – or anywhere that light is excluded from the skin – C. pepo fruits develop an orange spot that darkens as the fruit ripens. This spot may be large or small, depending on the fruit’s position, but regardless of the size of the spot it is the color that indicates ripeness – when the color of the spot looks as though the cinnamon has been stirred into the pumpkin pie filling, the squash are ready to harvest.

As an initial cue on pale Delicata-types, we also taught our crew to look for a dark green stem and a mellowing of the fruit color from yellow to an earthier shade before turning the squash over to check for the spot.

Cucurbita maximas, including Buttercups, Kabochas, and Hubbards, are characterized by their large, spongy stem that turns corky as it ripens. As the name indicates, these also tend to be the larger fruited varieties (in fact, the world-record “pumpkins” are actually maximas bred to resemble the traditional jack-o-lantern style squash). The first of the maximas tend to ripen after the first of the pepos. To judge ripeness, look at the amount of the stem that has turned corky – you want to see at least 75% of the stem take on a corky texture before harvest. A larger percentage of corky stem is also acceptable.

C. moschatas, such as the Butternuts and Cheese types, have rambling vines and a hard, angular stem that flares out noticeably where it meets the fruit. Most of these ripen from a greenish-hued fruit to more of a peanut color. The greenness also fades from the stem when the fruits are ripe.

At the outset of each squash season, I liked to walk through the field with the harvest crew sampling raw slices of the various varieties while looking at the harvest cues. It’s easy to taste the difference between marginally ripe fruits and the fruits that will make a customer sit up and take notice.

It’s worth noting that squash plants set flowers starting at the central stem, and continuing out along the vines. Fruits will ripen in this order, as well. If you find a ripe fruit, every fruit closer to the center of the plant is also likely to be ripe.

How to Harvest


To harvest, I like to cut the stem right where it joins the vine. Because we hand-packed our squash into crates and bins, we didn’t have to worry about squash bumping into each other and making gouges with the longer stems. If you’re using a harvest conveyor, you might want to cut the stems shorter, especially for the pepos and moschatas.

It’s important to make the cut square to the stem. For the hard-stemmed varieties, I like a sharp bypass pruners to make the cut. In my experience, long-handled loppers encouraged a stooped posture and were difficult to control precisely, whereas pruners provided a precise cut and encouraged more ergonomic squatting.

Curing is always a source of debate among squash enthusiasts. We settled on not curing our pepos, but going ahead and curing our maximas and moschatas. It certainly does no harm.

Curing is best done at 70 to 80 degrees F in a dry place – conditions that are not uncommon after the first frost in New England and the Upper Midwest. Squash can also be cured in boxes, as long as you ensure adequate air circulation.

Picture

3 Comments
Ashley
9/17/2015 08:01:26 pm

This is a really stellar breakdown, thank you so much! For our farm, I've always found acorn squash to be the most difficult to harvest.

On our farm, a lot of the leaf coverage dies back in late-August, early-September, often long before it frosts here in northern Virginia, which leaves certain varieties (acorns, mainly) more susceptible to sunscald than others. Often times, the acorns sunscald before they can produce that beautiful orange spot that indicates they're ready to be picked.

In your opinion -- and in this event of foliage die off -- is it better to harvest deep green, fully-sized acorn squash without the orange ripeness signifier around the time that your other pepos are ripe, or flirt with sunscald and hope some escape it and produce the orange spot? Essentially, is that orange spot the only way to know your acorn are going to be sweet and delicious?

Also, how do you manage the squash that fall off the vine when they're being examined for ripeness? Are they culled, left in the field or included in the harvest? That happens a lot with our crew and it's difficult to know which squash to harvest without taking a good look.

Lastly, I'm curious how prioritize pests in relationship to when you harvest the squash. This year a groundhog was having a premature Thanksgiving feast in one of our winter squash patches, forcing us to harvest sooner than we would have liked to. If you have pests threatening your winter squash yields, do you think it's better to leave them out there and hope you get something, protect them somehow, or harvest the most at-risk varieties slightly prematurely?

Reply
Chris Blanchard
9/18/2015 10:03:31 am

I love all of the questions, thank you, Ashley!

In my experience, that orange spot is really the only way to know what's going on inside of the pepos. Maturity varies by variety so much that unless you know by experience what's ready, I think it would be a challenge to guarantee the sweetness. You might try some taste-testing out in the field to make some decisions, but keep in mind that the squash on an individual plant and vine are going to ripen at different times.

If a squash falls of the vine, it's going to be done ripening. One way to help your crew avoid this problem is to have them work from the center of the plant or bed outwards - squash closer to the stem typically ripen first. Also, train them on those secondary indicators - deep green in the acorns, that richness of color on the delicata-types.

As far as pests go... I think you've really got to make that judgment call yourself - it's a quality versus yield question. Again, squash won't continue to ripen once you pick them. Sorry I don't have a quick answer to this one.

Especially with vertebrate pests like groundhogs, I would try to manage the pest rather than adjust the harvest. My favorite way to deal with a groundhog is to grab a lawn chair, a good book, and a .22 rifle. Set up where you can see the squash patch and read your book until the groundhog comes around, then change your focus. Groundhog troubles were actually what drove me to buy the first and only gun I've ever owned. This can be a pretty decent way to force yourself into a little bit of downtime, too - a great excuse to read a book!

I've also had fair luck with a live trap baited with something yummier than winter squash - my groundhogs were quite fond of sliced apples.

Reply
Crystal link
9/13/2018 09:58:08 am

This was SOOO incredibly helpful- thank you very much! This is exactly the scientific meets practical application squash harvesting info I’ve been looking for! Much appreciated!

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Picture

    Sponsors

    img_purple pitchfork_sponsor_vermont compost

    Archives

    2016
    2015

    2014
    2013
    2012
    2011

    Announcement
    Business Philosophy
    Business Strategy
    CSA
    Entrepreneurism
    Farm Equipment
    Farm Finances
    Farming Techniques
    Farm Labor
    Farm Systems
    Farm Wisdom
    Food Safety
    Government
    Health
    Irrigation
    Management
    Marketing
    Organic Certification
    Organic Farming
    Organization
    Pricing
    Records Management
    Scaling Up
    Value

    Picture

    RSS Feed

Contact
Copyright © 2018, Purple Pitchfork. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy